• Welcome to the Anxiety Community Forum, a friendly space for discussion, help and support with mental health issues. Please register to post and use the extra features available to members. Click here to register.Everyone is welcome!

Is it possible to not get affected by PTSD?

DylanRowan

DylanRowan

Junior Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2016
Messages
78
Reaction score
8
So, I am very curious about this. Maybe I should not be asking this because it might sound rude. But, can you not be affected by a hard event that happens in your life? I feel like it has to do with how mentally strong someone is. Saying mentally prepared, in my opinion, is wrong when it involves ptsd since the event comes randomly or out of nowhere. I know nothing about this since I have yet to experience it, so I might as well just ask others about it. So, it is possible not to get affected by it even if it's a very traumatic event? What exactly do you feel when remembering such event? Have you overcome such event easily?


Maybe I did not explain with the best order possible so feel free to ask any questions.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
P

Peachdejour

Junior Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2016
Messages
25
Reaction score
2
Sure. There are soldiers that come back from combat without PTSD and there are people who go through abuse that do not have PTSD also. Mental health issues are a combination of nature and nuture. So, it's not just what happens to you, but also how you are wired. Sometimes it can take several events to trigger PTSD or maybe only depression or anxiety will result.
 
HappyKoi

HappyKoi

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2016
Messages
252
Reaction score
43
I was just reading an article about this, and the idea that it has to do with mental "strength" is really a myth.  A lot of it is how the amygdala, the part of your brain located near the base that regulates emotions, processes events.  Since the amygdala isn't fully mature until a person is about 25 (and this is the average- some take longer), events from childhood or young adulthood have a very strong impact on how the brain reacts to stress.  So, like the person above me said, it is a combination of both your childhood and your brain development, your "wiring", so to speak.  The variety in the symptoms is partially cultural, partially related to the individual, which is why there is so much variety in symptoms and their severity.  Trying to overcome PTSD requires a person to rewire their basic survival impulses (because the amygdala is part of these and tied closely the "reptilian brain" which governs survival, like the impulse for people who are drowning to grab onto anything to stay above water), to work through the event that caused their brains to change in the first place, and to overcome an instinctual reaction, and it's about as easy as it sounds, being, obviously, not.
On that note, think about the idea that the amygdala isn't mature until about a person's mid-twenties, and we regularly send people who are younger that that in the military into active combat zones.  No wonder so many veterans have lifelong PTSD.
 
DylanRowan

DylanRowan

Junior Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2016
Messages
78
Reaction score
8
HappyKoi said:
I was just reading an article about this, and the idea that it has to do with mental "strength" is really a myth.  A lot of it is how the amygdala, the part of your brain located near the base that regulates emotions, processes events.  Since the amygdala isn't fully mature until a person is about 25 (and this is the average- some take longer), events from childhood or young adulthood have a very strong impact on how the brain reacts to stress.  So, like the person above me said, it is a combination of both your childhood and your brain development, your "wiring", so to speak.  The variety in the symptoms is partially cultural, partially related to the individual, which is why there is so much variety in symptoms and their severity.  Trying to overcome PTSD requires a person to rewire their basic survival impulses (because the amygdala is part of these and tied closely the "reptilian brain" which governs survival, like the impulse for people who are drowning to grab onto anything to stay above water), to work through the event that caused their brains to change in the first place, and to overcome an instinctual reaction, and it's about as easy as it sounds, being, obviously, not.
On that note, think about the idea that the amygdala isn't mature until about a person's mid-twenties, and we regularly send people who are younger that that in the military into active combat zones.  No wonder so many veterans have lifelong PTSD.
Click to expand...
I see. I should research more about this since I am curious about it. It seems that the amygdala plays a huge role in how we react to most situations.
 
Choochoo

Choochoo

New Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2016
Messages
148
Reaction score
11
I think the risk of it may be that you might not know you are affected but your subconscious might be and it might just manifest later on. I do think some people mature earlier or more than others though, despite circumstances,so maybe it has more to do with their natural personality and their ability to be more focused on themselves rather than fall victim to their environment or experiences. Probably the best measure of this is the ability of the person to be honest with themselves and how self aware they are of how their mind works so they don't risk just fooling themselves into thinking they are okay when they are not. 
 
Last edited by a moderator:
janemariesayed

janemariesayed

Moderator
Joined
Aug 31, 2016
Messages
2,417
Reaction score
509
DylanRowan said:
So, I am very curious about this. Maybe I should not be asking this because it might sound rude. But, can you not be affected by a hard event that happens in your life? I feel like it has to do with how mentally strong someone is. Saying mentally prepared, in my opinion, is wrong when it involves ptsd since the event comes randomly or out of nowhere. I know nothing about this since I have yet to experience it, so I might as well just ask others about it. So, it is possible not to get affected by it even if it's a very traumatic event? What exactly do you feel when remembering such event? Have you overcome such event easily?


Maybe I did not explain with the best order possible so feel free to ask any questions.
Click to expand...

That what affects us on the outside has an effect on the inside too. Long term trauma is what sets off PTSD. It doesn't always show up until a few months after the trauma has ceased either. Some people don't realise that they have it. It can be mild to severe or non existant. Some people are not affected by trauma. Not all soldiers who go to war get shellshock.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top